All sugar cookies have a vanilla base and are frosted with vanilla royal icing. Special flavors may be requested.
All base custom cookie orders start at $55 per dozen with a 2-dozen order minimum.
Prices increase depending on detail, designs, amount of colors, & lettering/logos. You will receive a quote once your cookies have been designed.
Once your cookie designs have been accepted and you received your quote, a 50% deposit is required to secure your date and order. All cookie availability is first-come first-serve.
Cookies are available for contactless, porch pick-up as Buttersweet Treats does not have a storefront. Cookies are securely packaged and safely set outside at a previously scheduled pick-up time.
Buttersweet Treats is a small, cottage bakery in Alexandria, VA. This means each cookie is actually HOMEMADE and individually crafted specifically for you. You'll want to submit a cookie inquiry form sooner than later, as we typically book out a few months in advance.
Hello!
I'm Christina, the cookie baker and decorator at Buttersweet Treats. I juggle a full-time job while pursuing my passion for cookie baking as a side venture! In my free time, I enjoy spending moments with my husband, Jeremy, and our two dogs, Bella and Millie.
From a young age, I’ve had a natural talent for art, which I chose to blend with one of my greatest passions—cookies! In February 2022, I took the exciting step of launching Buttersweet Treats to share my love for cookies at your significant life events! I take great pride in crafting cookies that are not only visually appealing but also delicious. My sugar cookies are delightfully soft and perfectly balanced in sweetness. Whether you’re celebrating a birthday or a wedding, I’m here to sprinkle a little sweetness on your special occasion.
"We ordered from Christina for our engagement party this summer and the cookies were a HIT! By the end of the party every cookie was gone (or hidden so we could take home ) and we got tons of compliments on how tasty and beautiful the cookies were!
Not only did Christina bring my vision to life for these cookies but she also made sure they safely made it all the way to Virginia Beach! We can’t wait to order more from Buttersweet Treats for our future events! "
Taylor Delaune, Norfolk, VA
"I have ordered from BST multiple times now. Christina is so detail oriented. Each cookie and cupcake is beautiful designed and not to mention DELICIOUS! I was so impressed with her ability to help me determine a theme for the desserts too when I was stuck.
I’m not usually a huge fan of sugar cookies because the frosting is usually hard. I don’t know what magic she does, but that is not the case with these! The cookies are sooo soft, even after a few days, and the frosting doesn’t harden. I absolutely love them!
100000/10 recommend!"
Hannah Moore,
Sterling, VA
"I ordered 3 dozen Cookies for my daughters baby shower. Her theme was “Sweet as a Peach” and Christina did an amazing job working the theme and my granddaughters name into the cookies! I highly recommend Buttersweet Treats and look forward to using them in the future!"
Dee Duggins,
Fredericksburg, VA
Thank you for your interest in ordering custom sugar cookies.
I will get back to you as soon as possible.
Christina,
Owner & Baker
Buttersweet Treats, LLC
Check us out on our socials